Top pickNYX Professional Makeup Butter GlossMost-reviewed lip gloss on Amazon — non-sticky tinted gloss under $6Amazon →
Buying guide · Best Lip Gloss · 2026
Best Lip Gloss on Amazon
Reviewed: NYX Butter Gloss, NYX Fat Oil, Burt's Bees Shimmer, and NYX Jelly Job. Best lip gloss on Amazon 2026 — non-sticky gloss, lip oil, and shimmer sets from $6.
Our verdict
Start with NYX Butter Gloss — 123K reviews is the most reliable signal in this category
At the under-$10 tier, texture matters more than price. NYX Butter Gloss is the straightforward tinted gloss and the easiest place to start; Fat Oil Lip Drip feels more like a hydrating oil. Choose the Burt's Bees shimmer set when several subtle shades are more useful than one glossy color, and NYX Jelly Job for a thicker, glassier finish. The formulas are different enough that review count alone should not decide it.
Detailed breakdown
Our top picks
Best overall
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
Most-reviewed lip gloss on Amazon — non-sticky tinted gloss under $6
Non-sticky formulaHigh-shineTinted sheerVanilla scent4.5★ · 123,000+ reviews
A non-sticky tinted lip gloss with a high-shine finish — sheer color payoff, vanilla scent, available in a wide range of shades.
Best for
Daily non-sticky gloss with real color at the lowest price in this guide. The review volume makes it the most dependable starting point in the category.
What stands out
123,762 reviews at 4.5★ is the most-reviewed lip gloss on Amazon — that volume surfaces quality issues early and makes this the most reliable quality signal in the category.
Before you buy
Order by specific shade — results vary by color name. Sheer, not opaque. The vanilla scent is mild but present.
Skip if
You want lip oil hydration or buildable opacity — NYX Fat Oil or Burt's Bees are better fits for those use cases.
Price history — 12 months
Best for hydration
NYX Professional Makeup Fat Oil Lip Drip
Dropper-format lip oil — gloss with 12-hour hydration at $6.70
Lip oil dropper12hr hydrationVegan formulaTinted sheer4.5★ · 24,000+ reviews
A tinted lip oil in a dropper format — vegan formula with a 12-hour hydration claim, glossy finish, lighter than traditional gloss.
Best for
Anyone who wants gloss and hydration in one step. The oil formula is more moisturizing than standard gloss without feeling heavy.
What stands out
The dropper format is different from any other pick in this guide — lighter, more buildable application versus a standard wand applicator. 24,369 reviews at 4.5★ confirms the formula holds up.
Before you buy
Dropper applicator takes adjustment vs. a standard gloss wand. Tinted but sheer — not full coverage. Color payout is lighter than Butter Gloss.
Skip if
You want maximum shine or a traditional gloss texture — NYX Butter Gloss is the classic high-shine pick.
Price history — 12 months
Best rated
Burt's Bees Shimmer Lip Tint Set
Highest-rated pick in the guide — 4 shimmer tints under $19
4-pack setLight shimmerMoisturizingNatural formula4.7★ · 7,000+ reviews
A 4-pack of shimmer lip tints — light natural shimmer, moisturizing formula, multiple shades in one purchase. Under $5 per tint.
Best for
Buyers who want multiple shades at once, a gift set, or a natural shimmer finish. The 4-pack value is better than buying shades individually.
What stands out
4.7★ across 7,082 reviews — highest-rated pick in this guide. The set format lets you test multiple finishes at once rather than committing to one shade.
Before you buy
These are tinted balms with shimmer, not high-shine gloss — different product type than the NYX picks. Less shine, more wearable daily.
Skip if
You want high-shine gloss — the Burt's Bees formula is closer to a tinted balm with shimmer than a classic gloss.
Price history — 12 months
Best jelly formula
NYX Professional Makeup Jelly Job Lip Gloss
Thicker jelly-texture gloss — more dimensional, hyper-glossy finish
Jelly textureHyper-glossyFull-bodied formulaSmoothing4.3★ · 1,000+ reviews
A jelly-finish lip gloss with a full-bodied, smoothing formula — hyper-glossy shine with more dimensional texture than standard gloss.
Best for
Anyone who wants a thicker, glassier finish than Butter Gloss — the jelly formula reads more editorial and dimensional.
What stands out
The jelly texture is distinctly different from the other NYX picks — thicker, more dimensional, and glossier in appearance. Different formula for a different result.
Before you buy
Newer product with 1,099 reviews — directionally reliable but less established than Butter Gloss (123K+ reviews). Jelly formula is stickier than Butter Gloss by design.
Skip if
You prefer lightweight non-sticky gloss — NYX Butter Gloss at $5.97 is the right pick. The jelly formula prioritizes shine over non-sticky feel.
Price history — 12 months
All 4 picks
Side by side
A direct comparison across the specs that actually matter for this category.
| Product | Best for | What stands out | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| NYX Professional Makeup Butter GlossTop pick | Daily non-sticky gloss with real color at the lowest price in this guide. The review volume makes it the most dependable starting point in the category. | 123,762 reviews at 4.5★ is the most-reviewed lip gloss on Amazon — that volume surfaces quality issues early and makes this the most reliable quality signal in the category. | $5–$8 |
| NYX Professional Makeup Fat Oil Lip Drip | Anyone who wants gloss and hydration in one step. The oil formula is more moisturizing than standard gloss without feeling heavy. | The dropper format is different from any other pick in this guide — lighter, more buildable application versus a standard wand applicator. 24,369 reviews at 4.5★ confirms the formula holds up. | $6–$9 |
| Burt's Bees Shimmer Lip Tint Set | Buyers who want multiple shades at once, a gift set, or a natural shimmer finish. The 4-pack value is better than buying shades individually. | 4.7★ across 7,082 reviews — highest-rated pick in this guide. The set format lets you test multiple finishes at once rather than committing to one shade. | $17–$22 |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jelly Job Lip Gloss | Anyone who wants a thicker, glassier finish than Butter Gloss — the jelly formula reads more editorial and dimensional. | The jelly texture is distinctly different from the other NYX picks — thicker, more dimensional, and glossier in appearance. Different formula for a different result. | $10–$14 |
What you get
Price tiers, honestly explained
Under $10
$5–$9
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss ★
NYX Professional Makeup Fat Oil Lip Drip
NYX Butter Gloss ($5.97) is the entry point — 123K reviews makes it the most reliable signal. Fat Oil Lip Drip ($6.70) adds a dropper format and 12hr hydration claim at the same price tier.
$10–$15
$10–$14
NYX Professional Makeup Jelly Job Lip Gloss
Jelly-texture formula with a thicker, more dimensional finish than standard gloss — the editorial option in this guide.
$15–$25
$17–$22
Burt's Bees Shimmer Lip Tint Set
4 shimmer tints for $18.88 — highest-rated pick in the guide (4.7★). Under $5 per tint when bought as a set. Best for testing multiple shades or gifting.
What to avoid
Common buying mistakes
Ordering a shade without reading the shade description — "clear" and "nude" read very differently across skin tones
Expecting Burt's Bees to feel like gloss — it's a shimmer tint balm, not a high-shine gloss
Buying the Jelly Job expecting non-sticky — it's stickier than Butter Gloss by design
Ordering a single NYX Butter Gloss without knowing what color you need — check the shade name and reviews for that specific color before committing
FAQ
Questions worth answering
What's the difference between NYX Butter Gloss and Fat Oil Lip Drip?
Butter Gloss is a classic wand-applicator lip gloss — non-sticky, high-shine, sheer tint. Fat Oil is a dropper-format lip oil — lighter application, oil formula with a hydration claim, buildable sheer tint. Both are $5–$7. Choose based on texture preference: wand gloss vs. dropper oil.
Is NYX Butter Gloss really non-sticky?
Per 123,000+ reviews: yes, it's consistently called out as less sticky than comparable glosses. It's not completely no-feel, but it doesn't have the old-school thick-sticky texture. That's the main reason it has 123K reviews at 4.5★.
What's the best lip gloss for a natural glow look?
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip or Burt's Bees Shimmer Lip Tint — the Fat Oil gives a glossy, natural lip-oil look; the Burt's Bees shimmer gives a wearable everyday shimmer that reads more subtle than classic gloss. For maximum natural shine, NYX Butter Gloss in a clear or barely-there nude shade.
Is the Burt's Bees shimmer set good for gifting?
Yes — 4 shades in one package at $18.88 means multiple colors to try, and the Burt's Bees brand is widely recognizable. The shimmer tints are wearable across most complexions. Good gift pick for someone who prefers a natural-ingredient formula.
Our recommendation
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
A non-sticky tinted lip gloss with a high-shine finish — sheer color payoff, vanilla scent, available in a wide range of shades.
Check price on Amazon
Prices verified May 4, 2026 · Affiliate commission may apply