Best Lip Gloss on Amazon
Reviewed: NYX Butter Gloss, NYX Fat Oil, Burt's Bees Shimmer, and NYX Jelly Job. Best lip gloss on Amazon 2026 — non-sticky gloss, lip oil, and shimmer sets from $6.
Start with NYX Butter Gloss — 123K reviews is the most reliable signal in this category
At the under-$10 tier, texture matters more than price. NYX Butter Gloss is the straightforward tinted gloss and the easiest place to start; Fat Oil Lip Drip feels more like a hydrating oil. Choose the Burt's Bees shimmer set when several subtle shades are more useful than one glossy color, and NYX Jelly Job for a thicker, glassier finish. The formulas are different enough that review count alone should not decide it.
Our top picks
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
A non-sticky tinted lip gloss with a high-shine finish — sheer color payoff, vanilla scent, available in a wide range of shades.
NYX Professional Makeup Fat Oil Lip Drip
A tinted lip oil in a dropper format — vegan formula with a 12-hour hydration claim, glossy finish, lighter than traditional gloss.
Burt's Bees Shimmer Lip Tint Set
A 4-pack of shimmer lip tints — light natural shimmer, moisturizing formula, multiple shades in one purchase. Under $5 per tint.
NYX Professional Makeup Jelly Job Lip Gloss
A jelly-finish lip gloss with a full-bodied, smoothing formula — hyper-glossy shine with more dimensional texture than standard gloss.
Side by side
A direct comparison across the specs that actually matter for this category.
| Product | Best for | What stands out | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| NYX Professional Makeup Butter GlossTop pick | Daily non-sticky gloss with real color at the lowest price in this guide. The review volume makes it the most dependable starting point in the category. | 123,762 reviews at 4.5★ is the most-reviewed lip gloss on Amazon — that volume surfaces quality issues early and makes this the most reliable quality signal in the category. | $5–$8 |
| NYX Professional Makeup Fat Oil Lip Drip | Anyone who wants gloss and hydration in one step. The oil formula is more moisturizing than standard gloss without feeling heavy. | The dropper format is different from any other pick in this guide — lighter, more buildable application versus a standard wand applicator. 24,369 reviews at 4.5★ confirms the formula holds up. | $6–$9 |
| Burt's Bees Shimmer Lip Tint Set | Buyers who want multiple shades at once, a gift set, or a natural shimmer finish. The 4-pack value is better than buying shades individually. | 4.7★ across 7,082 reviews — highest-rated pick in this guide. The set format lets you test multiple finishes at once rather than committing to one shade. | $17–$22 |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jelly Job Lip Gloss | Anyone who wants a thicker, glassier finish than Butter Gloss — the jelly formula reads more editorial and dimensional. | The jelly texture is distinctly different from the other NYX picks — thicker, more dimensional, and glossier in appearance. Different formula for a different result. | $10–$14 |
Price tiers, honestly explained
Common buying mistakes
Questions worth answering
What's the difference between NYX Butter Gloss and Fat Oil Lip Drip?
Butter Gloss is a classic wand-applicator lip gloss — non-sticky, high-shine, sheer tint. Fat Oil is a dropper-format lip oil — lighter application, oil formula with a hydration claim, buildable sheer tint. Both are $5–$7. Choose based on texture preference: wand gloss vs. dropper oil.
Is NYX Butter Gloss really non-sticky?
Per 123,000+ reviews: yes, it's consistently called out as less sticky than comparable glosses. It's not completely no-feel, but it doesn't have the old-school thick-sticky texture. That's the main reason it has 123K reviews at 4.5★.
What's the best lip gloss for a natural glow look?
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip or Burt's Bees Shimmer Lip Tint — the Fat Oil gives a glossy, natural lip-oil look; the Burt's Bees shimmer gives a wearable everyday shimmer that reads more subtle than classic gloss. For maximum natural shine, NYX Butter Gloss in a clear or barely-there nude shade.
Is the Burt's Bees shimmer set good for gifting?
Yes — 4 shades in one package at $18.88 means multiple colors to try, and the Burt's Bees brand is widely recognizable. The shimmer tints are wearable across most complexions. Good gift pick for someone who prefers a natural-ingredient formula.
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
A non-sticky tinted lip gloss with a high-shine finish — sheer color payoff, vanilla scent, available in a wide range of shades.